UNPERMITTED REMODELING – WHAT MUST SELLERS DISCLOSE?
What Must Sellers Disclose?
Oregon’s Property Disclosure form asks sellers whether they have had any additions, conversions or remodeling to the home. If the answer is “yes” the form asks three follow-up questions; (1) Was a building permit required? (2) Was a building permit obtained? (3) Was a final inspection obtained?
If the work was performed by a contractor, the owner may incorrectly assume that it was legally permitted and inspected.
For all of the above reasons, Realtors® should be alert to the distinct possibility that a seller’s answers to questions concerning remodeling may not always be totally reliable, even when made in good faith.
While Oregon law does not require that real estate agents be “experts” on the issue of code compliance, it does not permit them to close their eyes to the obvious. If the home’s garage or attic has been converted to a sleeping area, an older home is advertised as having been “updated,” or the style of kitchen or bathroom obviously post-dates the home’s original construction, the question must be asked whether the work was permitted and inspected. This question should be asked regardless of the seller’s answers in the property disclosure form – in other words “trust but verify.”
There are several reasons for following this practice:
When is a Permit Required?1
The answer to this question is not always clear and sometimes confusing – which is why sellers’ answers in the property disclosure form can vary dramatically.2 First, owners themselves may perform certain work on their own home, without hiring a licensed contractor.3 However, homeowners performing their own work are still subject to the same permit requirements as required of licensed contractors that is. they all must apply for and obtain a permit and have the work inspected for code compliance.
If the work involves interior plumbing, such as repair, replacement, or relocation of lines, chances are a permit is required. The same holds true for new plumbing fixtures, such as toilets, sinks, tubes, etc. Even replacing an existing fixture, such as a tub or shower, can require a permit, if it involves concealed plumbing connections. A permit is not required to replace accessible plumbing fixtures or to make certain emergency repairs. If a bathroom is added to a home, this may involve obtaining not only a plumbing permit, but a building permit, an electrical permit and mechanical permits.
Work involving exterior plumbing such as sewer lines, septic systems, cesspools and drywells can require a permit. In some instances, the contractor must also be licensed by the Oregon DEQ.
Repair, replacement or installation performed on heating, cooling or ventilation systems is known as “mechanical” work for which a permit may be required. This can include installing or changing any part of a home’s heating or cooling systems, wood stoves, fireplace inserts, gas piping or fuel oil tanks.
When electrical work is done on a home by the owner, he/she must also be the occupant – otherwise a state licensed contractor must perform the work. A permit is required to install, change or repair any hard-wired system. This includes additional wiring, adding an electrical outlet or light fixture, or changing a fuse box to circuit breakers. Even installation of low voltage systems such as phone or security systems can require a permit.
Building permits are required almost any time a dwelling is enlarged or altered in any material way. Examples would include finishing an attic, garage, basement, moving or adding walls, some deck and porch construction, etc. When building permits are not required, but there are concerns about how the site is used, a zoning permit may be required. For example, enlarging a driveway or paving a parking area, may require the owner to obtain a zoning permit.
Permits, if required, must be purchased before the work is performed. Any work performed under a permit must be inspected for code compliance. The permit expires after 180 days if it has not been inspected. If the city or county becomes aware that work has been performed without the necessary permit(s), the homeowner will be notified by mail to either purchase the necessary permit, or in the case of more complex work, to submit plans to the proper authorities. If the requested action is not obtained, the matter is turned over to code compliance authorities for follow-up. If necessary, the authorities have the power to take administrative action or issue fines against the owner of a home if the necessary permits were never issued. Since the enforcement action is against the record owner of the home, in those cases in which the home has been sold, this means the innocent buyer is saddled with their seller’s noncompliance.
There are many reasons why homes may not be code compliant, ranging from a failure to realize the need to obtain a permit, to acquiring a home that had alterations performed by the prior owner. The Portland Bureau of Development Services, which is charged with responsibility for ensuring that construction is properly permitted and code compliant, has a website that permits anyone to check into the permit history of a property by simply entering the address. For further information, go to: http://www.portlandonline.com/bds/index.cfm?c=34194.
After a home has been sold, the new owner may be saddled with the expense and responsibility for making a home code compliant. In some cases, the time and cost can be substantial. Now that seller property disclosure is required to be given, owners have very little “wiggle room” to avoid addressing the issue of whether any remodeling was ever performed, whether a permit was ever issued and whether the work was ever inspected and passed. The longer the owner owned the home, the greater the likelihood he/she knows its remodeling history.
In this litigious society, Realtors® cannot act on blind faith alone. Listing agents should make sure their sellers understand the risk in giving untruthful answers, and buyer agents should make sure their buyers understand the need to verify with the local jurisdiction exactly what work has (or has not) been permitted, inspected and passed. It is this type of value that Realtors® can bring to a transaction, and in so doing, justify their earning a nice commission.
© 2010 QUERIN LAW, LLC
1 Much of the following information was obtained from the Portland Bureau of Development Services. Their website is http://www.bds.ci.portland.or.us/. It can be a very useful resource for both Realtors® and their clients.
2 Remember, the form only requires that the seller’s answers be based upon his/her “actual knowledge.” If the seller truly doesn’t know whether a permit was required, or truly believed one was not required, it will be very difficult for a buyer to prove that the seller knew they were not telling the truth at the time they completed and signed the disclosure form.
3 The “owner” is the person named on the title – not a family member or friend of the owner.